Rebutting Rebuttals: Evaluating the impact of the conference review rebuttal process.

Saved in:

Bibliographic Details
Title:	Rebutting Rebuttals: Evaluating the impact of the conference review rebuttal process.
Authors:	Dershowitz, Nachum¹ nachum@tau.ac.il, Verma, Rakesh M.² rmverma2@central.uh.edu
Source:	Communications of the ACM. Sep2023, Vol. 66 Issue 9, p35-41. 7p. 1 Color Photograph, 1 Diagram, 4 Charts, 4 Graphs.
Subjects:	Scholarly peer review, Computer science conferences, Research personnel, Decision making, Conference proceedings (Publications)
Abstract:	This research article examines the conference review rebuttal process, which is an opportunity for researchers to answer specific questions and/or address general concerns peer reviewers have about their research, and whether rebuttal ultimately affects the approval/rejection decision in conference acceptance. The authors review data from five conferences in the computing science field and present their findings as well as a brief look into alternative refereeing processes.
Database:	Engineering Source

Description
Abstract:	This research article examines the conference review rebuttal process, which is an opportunity for researchers to answer specific questions and/or address general concerns peer reviewers have about their research, and whether rebuttal ultimately affects the approval/rejection decision in conference acceptance. The authors review data from five conferences in the computing science field and present their findings as well as a brief look into alternative refereeing processes.
ISSN:	00010782
DOI:	10.1145/3584664